Accounting Firms

Turning a PCAOB Remediation Crisis into a Compliance Success

Published on11 March 2025

The Challenge

A PCAOB-registered firm underwent its triennial PCAOB inspection and, the following year, found itself deep into its 12-month remediation period for quality control criticisms. With only two months left, the firm had an initial response drafted but lacked regular PCAOB communication and a clear action plan. Struggling to make meaningful progress, the firm was close to giving up and risked having its Part II report made public.  

The Solution  

Recognizing the urgency, the firm engaged CPAClub as its external quality control specialist. Our team, led by a former PCAOB director, quickly took action by: 

  • Reviewing the firm’s draft response and providing strategic, actionable feedback.
  • Developing a targeted remediation plan that was shared with the PCAOB.
  • Implementing immediate and long-term solutions, including CPE training, structured communications, and a pre-issuance review program.

The Impact

With CPAClub’s guidance, the firm successfully navigated its PCAOB remediation, resulting in: 

  • Successful Outcome: The PCAOB confirmed it would not make the firm’s Part II quality control criticisms public.
  • Strategic Compliance Plan: A sustainable framework was established to strengthen the firm’s quality control processes.
  • Cost-Effective Expertise: Instead of hiring a full-time Quality Control Director at a $300,000 salary, the firm leveraged CPAClub’s deep expertise at a fraction of the cost.

By partnering with CPAClub, the firm not only avoided public scrutiny but also gained a long-term, scalable approach to quality control—without the burden of maintaining an in-house quality control function.  

About CPAClub

CPAClub is transforming how public accounting firms and companies meet accounting, advisory and assurance requirements by turning the traditional model upside down. Founded and led by one of Accounting Today’s Top 100 Most Influential People in Accounting and one of CPA Practice Advisor’s 20 Under 40 Top Influencers, CPAClub was recognized as a Top New Product by Accounting Today. CPAClub offers onshore accounting, advisory and assurance solutions throughout the United States and abroad via its award-winning subscription model. Learn more at cpaclub.cpa.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Subscribe to receive the latest thought leadership posts to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.
Share This Post

See More Success Stories

Accounting Firms
The Challenge A global accounting firm with more than 600 service professionals sought to strengthen its audit quality and regulatory compliance in response to PCAOB expectations. Initially focused on enhancing its engagement quality review (EQR) process, the firm engaged CPAClub to refine its approach, address PCAOB feedback more effectively, and implement best practices to elevate...
Companies
The Challenge A company found itself in a difficult situation when its existing CPA firm, overwhelmed with other commitments, became unresponsive. With the deadline for their employee benefit plan financial statement audit rapidly approaching, the company had no clear path forward. While they understood the importance of compliance, they lacked the support needed to meet...
Accounting Firms
The Challenge A well-established local tax and accounting firm faced a critical challenge when an audit manager unexpectedly departed, leaving a gap in its assurance and audit practice. The firm struggled to maintain operations, meet client deadlines, and ensure engagement quality without an experienced manager. Traditional staffing solutions were too rigid and reactive, making it...
Accounting Firms
A public accountant can help you determine the most appropriate business structure, analyze your business plan for financial compatibility, and advise you on the best decisions to maximize your finances. For that reason, careers in public accounting are on the rise. Here are five reasons to choose external auditing as a career. 1. You’ll Have...
Accounting Firms, Companies, Five Points
The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) is set to embark on a new journey with the announcement of Mark Koziel as its incoming president. Currently serving as the CEO of Allinial Global, Koziel’s leadership promises to address pressing issues within the accounting profession. Here are five key points to consider regarding Koziel’s vision...
logo-calcpa
CalCPA Firm of the Year
Thank you to our members, crew, and allies. See why they trust us to lead the way.