The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) finalized new rules that will require audit firms to report a range of firm- and engagement-level metrics, marking a significant shift in how audit quality is measured and reported. These changes aim to enhance transparency in the audit process, giving investors, audit committees, and the public more insight into audit quality. Here are five key points CPA firms should know about the PCAOB’s new reporting requirements.
1. New Reporting Requirements for Firms and Engagements
Under the final rules, certain audit firms will be required to report both firm-level and engagement-level metrics. Firm-level metrics will provide insights into the overall structure and resources of an audit firm, such as the experience of senior personnel and retention rates. Engagement-level metrics will focus on specific audits, detailing the experience and workload of the engagement team, including the engagement partner and quality reviewer. These metrics are designed to provide a clearer picture of the audit process, helping stakeholders assess audit quality more effectively.
2. Long History Behind These Changes
These new rules didn’t come about overnight. They build on over 16 years of input, including recommendations from the Advisory Committee on the Auditing Profession (ACAP) in 2008 and the PCAOB’s 2015 Concept Release on audit quality indicators. Our founder and president, Chris Vanover, was involved in developing the initial audit quality framework and a set of audit quality indicators during his time at the PCAOB, which laid the groundwork for the metrics we’re seeing today. These final rules are the culmination of years of feedback and research aimed at improving transparency in the audit process.
3. The Goal: Shifting Focus to Audit Quality
The PCAOB, along with investors and audit committees, is working to ensure that firms compete on audit quality, rather than just on price. For years, firms have been competing on the lowest bid, but this often doesn’t reflect the true quality of the audit performed. With these new metrics, the focus will shift to factors that truly impact audit quality—such as the experience and involvement of senior auditors, training levels, and industry-specific expertise—allowing firms to differentiate themselves based on the value they provide, not just cost.
4. Metrics Focus on Audit Personnel and Staffing
The new rules require reporting on eight key areas, with a significant focus on audit personnel. These metrics will provide new insights into how audits are staffed, including the extent of senior personnel involvement, the overall workload of auditors, the retention of key staff, and the levels of training and industry-specific experience. These metrics will allow investors and audit committees to better understand the resources behind each audit, helping them make more informed decisions about which auditors to trust.
5. Timeline for Implementation
If approved by the SEC, these reporting requirements will go into effect on October 1, 2027. Firms that audit accelerated or large accelerated filers will be required to report on firm and engagement-level metrics starting that year, with phased implementation based on firm size. Larger firms will begin reporting first, followed by smaller firms the following year. This phased approach ensures that firms have time to adjust to the new requirements, with larger firms leading the way in providing transparency.
Conclusion
The PCAOB’s new firm and engagement-level reporting rules are a game-changer for the audit industry. By focusing on audit quality rather than price, these rules aim to provide more transparency into the audit process, helping investors and audit committees make better-informed decisions. While the implementation of these rules is still a few years away, CPA firms should start preparing now to ensure they’re ready for the changes ahead. By staying proactive, firms can position themselves to take advantage of this shift toward greater transparency and accountability in the audit industry.
Elevate Your CPA Firm with CPAClub
Discover how CPAClub can enhance your firm’s quality management and compliance efforts while driving growth and efficiency. Learn more at cpaclub.cpa/quality-management.
About CPAClub
CPAClub is transforming how CPA firms and companies meet accounting, advisory and assurance requirements by turning the traditional model upside down. Founded and led by one of Accounting Today’s Top 100 Most Influential People in Accounting and one of CPA Practice Advisor’s 20 Under 40 Top Influencers, CPAClub was recognized as a Top New Product by Accounting Today. CPAClub offers onshore accounting, advisory and assurance solutions to top 10, regional and local CPA firms and companies throughout the United States and abroad via its award-winning membership model. Learn more at cpaclub.cpa and cpaclub.cpa/quality-management.
